Welcome to Mattressnap, where we dive deep into the world of sleep to help you find the perfect mattress. Today, we’re comparing two heavyweights in the luxury mattress market: Saatva and Avocado. Both brands are known for their high-quality, eco-friendly designs, but they cater to slightly different needs and preferences. Whether you’re after plush comfort, organic materials, or a mattress that suits your unique sleep style, this in-depth comparison will guide you to the right choice. Let’s break it down!
Saatva
Saatva is a brand synonymous with luxury at an accessible price point. Their flagship Saatva Classic is a coil-on-coil innerspring hybrid that feels like a high-end hotel bed. They also offer the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid, a newer model blending memory foam with coils for a more contouring feel. Saatva stands out for its customization options, white-glove delivery, and a focus on durability and lumbar support.
Best For
- Combination sleepers who switch positions and need responsiveness.
- Back and stomach sleepers seeking strong lumbar support.
- Seniors or those who value free white-glove delivery and setup.
- Luxury shoppers wanting a premium feel without the hefty price tag.
Avocado
Avocado is the go-to for eco-conscious sleepers. Their Avocado Green and Avocado Eco Organic mattresses are hybrid designs made with organic latex, cotton, and wool. The brand emphasizes sustainability, non-toxic materials, and certifications like GOTS and GOLS. Avocado mattresses are firm, bouncy, and designed to last, appealing to those who prioritize green living and a natural sleep environment.
Best For
- Eco-conscious buyers who want certified organic materials.
- Back and stomach sleepers needing firm support for spinal alignment.
- Hot sleepers looking for breathable, cooling materials.
- Allergy sufferers seeking hypoallergenic, non-toxic beds.
Our Verdict
Choosing between Saatva and Avocado depends on your priorities. If you want a luxurious, customizable mattress with a traditional innerspring feel, Saatva is the winner. Its multiple firmness and height options, stellar lumbar support, and white-glove delivery make it ideal for those seeking a premium experience. However, if sustainability and organic materials are non-negotiable, Avocado takes the crown. Its eco-friendly design, cooling latex, and durability appeal to green-minded sleepers. Both brands excel in quality, but their strengths cater to different needs.
Performance Tests
Saatva vs. Avocado: Which Is the Winner?
Saatva generally scores higher in overall performance(Saatva Classic at 9.74/10), thanks to its versatility and customization. Avocado shines in eco-friendliness and cooling, but its firmer feel may not suit everyone. Let’s dive into the specifics.
Cooling Test
Both brands prioritize breathability, but their materials create different cooling experiences.
Saatva Classic Cooling Test
The Saatva Classic uses a breathable organic cotton cover and dual coil layers for airflow. Its pillow-top design can trap some heat, but the innerspring construction keeps it cooler than most memory foam beds. Sleepopolis notes it’s great for average sleepers but not the coolest for very hot sleepers.
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid Cooling Test
This model incorporates gel-infused memory foam and coils. The gel helps dissipate heat, and the coils promote airflow, making it slightly cooler than the Classic for those who like a foam feel (Mattress Clarity).
Avocado Green Cooling Test
The Avocado Green is a standout for cooling. Its organic latex and wool layers are naturally breathable, and the pocketed coils enhance airflow. U.S. News praises its ability to stay cool, ideal for hot sleepers.
Avocado Eco Cooling Test
Similar to the Green, the Eco uses latex and coils for excellent breathability. It scores slightly lower due to its simpler design but still outperforms many non-latex hybrids.
Winner: Avocado, for its superior cooling thanks to latex and wool.
Sinkage Test
Sinkage measures how much you sink into a mattress, affecting comfort and ease of movement.
Saatva Classic
The Classic has deeper sinkage (around 2 inches), creating a cradling feel, especially in the Plush Soft and Luxury Firm versions. This suits those who like a “hugged” sensation.
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid
With minimal sinkage (1.5 inches), this model feels like you’re sleeping “on” the bed, ideal for those who want less contouring.
Avocado Green
The Green has moderate sinkage (1.8 inches), offering a balanced feel. Its latex provides a buoyant, “floating” sensation (Sleepopolis).
Avocado Eco
The Eco has the most sinkage (2.2 inches) of the group, giving a slightly deeper hug, which some side sleepers may appreciate.
Winner: Tie. Saatva Classic for deeper sinkage lovers; Avocado Eco for a balanced organic option.
Motion Transfer
Motion transfer is key for couples, as it measures how much movement one partner feels from the other.
Saatva Classic Motion Transfer
The Classic’s dual coils and foam layers absorb some motion, but its springy nature allows more transfer than all-foam beds. It’s decent but not ideal for light sleepers (Sleep Foundation).
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid Motion Transfer
This model performs better, with gel memory foam reducing motion transfer significantly, making it better for couples (Mattress Clarity).
Avocado Green Motion Transfer
The Green’s latex and coils allow more motion transfer than desired, per U.S. News. It’s not the best for restless partners.
Avocado Eco Motion Transfer
The Eco has the lowest motion transfer of the group, thanks to its simpler latex design, making it a solid choice for couples .
Winner: Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid, for better motion isolation.
Response Test
Response time measures how quickly a mattress adjusts to movement, crucial for combination sleepers.
Saatva Classic Response Test
The Classic is highly responsive, with coils and foam snapping back in under 0.5 seconds. Great for easy position changes.
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid Response Test
Slightly slower (0.7 seconds) due to memory foam, but still quick enough for most sleepers (Mattress Clarity).
Avocado Green Response Test
The Green’s latex is ultra-responsive (0.4 seconds), making it one of the bounciest options (Sleepopolis).
Avocado Eco Response Test
Similar to the Green, the Eco responds in 0.4 seconds, perfect for active sleepers.
Winner: Avocado, for its lightning-fast latex response.
Bounce Test
Bounce affects ease of movement and suitability for intimate activities.
Saatva Classic Bounce Test
High bounce (10.5 inches, per ) makes it springy and easy to move on, great for combination sleepers.
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid Bounce Test
Moderate bounce (9 inches) balances responsiveness with contouring (Mattress Clarity).
Avocado Green Bounce Test
Very high bounce (11.54 inches), the Green is lively and responsive, per.
Avocado Eco Bounce Test
Similar to the Green, the Eco has high bounce (11 inches), ideal for active sleepers (Sleepopolis).
Winner: Avocado Green, for maximum bounce.
Edge Support Test
Edge support ensures stability when sitting or sleeping near the mattress edge.
Saatva Classic
Excellent edge support with foam rails and sturdy coils. Testers note minimal sinkage when sitting (U.S. News).
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid
Strong edge support, though slightly less robust than the Classic due to foam layers (Mattress Clarity).
Avocado Green
Very supportive edges with reinforced coils, great for sitting and sleeping (U.S. News).
Avocado Eco
Good edge support, but less robust than the Green due to simpler construction.
Winner: Saatva Classic, for top-tier edge support.
Sex Test
Both brands score well for intimacy due to high bounce, responsiveness, and edge support. Avocado’s cooling and quieter latex give it a slight edge, while Saatva’s deeper sinkage may appeal to some (Sleep Advisor).
Winner: Avocado, for cooling and quiet performance.
Pressure Relief Test
Pressure relief is critical for side sleepers and those with joint pain.
- Saatva Classic: Good pressure relief in the Luxury Firm and Plush Soft versions, but less ideal for strict side sleepers (Sleep Foundation).
- Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid: Better for side sleepers due to contouring foam (Mattress Clarity).
- Avocado Green: Moderate pressure relief; may feel too firm for lighter side sleepers (U.S. News).
- Avocado Eco: Slightly better pressure relief with optional pillow top (Sleepopolis).
Winner: Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid, for balanced relief.
Off-Gassing Test
- Saatva: Minimal off-gassing, with no strong odors due to uncompressed delivery (Sleepopolis).
- Avocado: Virtually no off-gassing, thanks to organic materials (CNET).
Winner: Avocado, for zero chemical smell.
Company
- Saatva: Offers a 365-night trial, lifetime warranty, and free white-glove delivery. Returns incur a $99 fee (Saatva.com).
- Avocado: Provides a 365-night trial, 25-year warranty, and free shipping (bed-in-a-box). Returns are free (AvocadoGreenMattress.com).
Winner: Saatva, for white-glove delivery and longer warranty.
Firmness
- Saatva Classic: Three options—Plush Soft (4/10), Luxury Firm (6.5/10), Firm (8/10). Luxury Firm is the most popular (Sleep Advisor).
- Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid: Medium-firm (6.5/10), balancing contouring and support (Mattress Clarity).
- Avocado Green: Medium-firm (7/10), slightly firmer without pillow top (U.S. News).
- Avocado Eco: Medium-firm (6.5/10), softer with optional pillow top (Sleepopolis).
Best for: Saatva for customizable firmness; Avocado for firm, supportive feel.
Support & Sleeping Positions
- Saatva Classic: Excels for back and stomach sleepers with zoned coil support. Luxury Firm suits most; Plush Soft for lighter side sleepers (Wirecutter).
- Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid: Great for side and back sleepers, with foam contouring hips and shoulders (Mattress Clarity).
- Avocado Green: Ideal for back and stomach sleepers; may be too firm for lighter side sleepers unless pillow-topped (U.S. News).
- Avocado Eco: Supports back and combination sleepers; pillow top helps side sleepers (Sleepopolis).
Best for: Saatva for versatile support; Avocado for firm alignment.
Design
Both brands use hybrid designs, but their approaches differ:
- Saatva: Focuses on luxury with coil-on-coil or foam-coil hybrids, emphasizing lumbar support and customization.
- Avocado: Prioritizes organic latex hybrids with a bouncy, eco-friendly feel.
Best for: Saatva for traditional luxury; Avocado for natural simplicity.
Materials
Saatva Classic
- Organic cotton cover with antimicrobial treatment.
- 3-inch Euro pillow top.
- Memory foam layer for pressure relief.
- Pocketed coils (recycled steel) for zoned support.
- Base coil layer for durability (Saatva.com).
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid
- Organic cotton cover.
- Gel-infused memory foam for cooling.
- Pocketed coils for support (Mattress Clarity).
Avocado Green
- GOTS organic cotton cover.
- GOLS organic latex (2 inches).
- Organic wool for breathability.
- Pocketed coils (recycled steel) with zoned support (AvocadoGreenMattress.com).
Avocado Eco
- Organic cotton and wool cover.
- 2-inch organic latex layer.
- Pocketed coils for support (Sleepopolis).
Best for: Avocado for certified organic materials; Saatva for luxurious layering.
Which Mattress Should You Buy?
Should You Buy the Saatva Classic?
- You want a customizable, hotel-like mattress.
- You need strong lumbar support for back or stomach sleeping.
- You value white-glove delivery and a lifetime warranty.
- Price: ~$1,199–$2,595 (Queen: ~$1,995) (Saatva.com).
Should You Buy the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid?
- You prefer a balance of memory foam contouring and coil support.
- You’re a side or back sleeper needing pressure relief.
- You want a cooler foam hybrid.
- Price: ~$1,099–$2,295 (Queen: ~$1,795) (Saatva.com).
Should You Buy the Avocado Green?
- You prioritize organic, non-toxic materials.
- You’re a back or stomach sleeper needing firm support.
- You sleep hot and want a bouncy, cooling bed.
- Price: ~$1,099–$2,399 (Queen: ~$1,799) (AvocadoGreenMattress.com).
Should You Buy the Avocado Eco?
- You want an affordable organic mattress.
- You’re a back or combination sleeper on a budget.
- You prefer a slightly softer feel with optional pillow top.
- Price: ~$699–$1,499 (Queen: ~$999) (AvocadoGreenMattress.com).
Final Thoughts
At Mattressnap, we believe both Saatva and Avocado offer exceptional mattresses, but your choice hinges on what matters most. Saatva is perfect for those craving a luxurious, customizable sleep experience with top-notch support and service. Avocado is the dream pick for eco-warriors who want a firm, cooling, and sustainable bed. Consider your sleep style, budget, and values, and you can’t go wrong with either. Ready to sleep better? Check out Saatva and Avocado’s websites for the latest deals!
