Hey there, mattress shoppers! If you’re torn between the Loom & Leaf by Saatva and a Tempurpedic mattress, you’re not alone. Both brands are heavyweights in the memory foam world, promising that classic, hug-like feel with premium comfort. But which one’s right for you? At Mattressnap, we’ve dug deep into reviews, performance tests, and real-world feedback to bring you this head-to-head comparison. Let’s break it down in simple terms, so you can sleep soundly on your decision.
Loom & Leaf
The Loom & Leaf is Saatva’s all-foam luxury mattress, designed to deliver a high-end memory foam experience at a more accessible price point. Available in two firmness levels—Relaxed Firm (5.5/10) and Firm (8/10)—it’s built with premium materials like gel-infused memory foam and organic cotton. It’s known for deep sinkage, excellent pressure relief, and a cooling gel layer that tackles heat retention, a common memory foam complaint. With a 12-inch profile, free White Glove delivery, and a 365-night trial, it’s a strong contender for those seeking value without sacrificing quality.
Best For
- Side sleepers who need cushioning at the hips and shoulders.
- Couples looking for minimal motion transfer.
- Hot sleepers wanting better cooling than traditional memory foam.
- Budget-conscious luxury seekers who want high-end features for less.
Tempurpedic
Tempurpedic is the OG of memory foam, pioneering the material in the ‘90s with NASA-inspired technology. Known for its slow-sinking, cradling feel, Tempurpedic offers models like the TEMPUR-Cloud, ProAdapt, and Breeze, with firmness options ranging from soft (3/10) to firm (7/10). The brand emphasizes motion isolation, pressure relief, and durability, but it comes with a premium price tag and often less impressive cooling. Tempurpedic mattresses typically have a 10-13-inch profile and a 90-night trial.
Best For
- Fans of classic memory foam who love a deep, contouring hug.
- Lightweight side sleepers (under 230 lbs) needing pressure relief.
- Couples prioritizing zero motion transfer.
- Brand loyalists willing to pay for Tempurpedic’s reputation.
Our Verdict
Both mattresses deliver that iconic memory foam feel, but they cater to slightly different needs. Loom & Leaf shines for its cooling, deeper sinkage, and value, making it ideal for hot sleepers and those who want luxury on a budget. Tempurpedic excels in motion isolation and brand prestige but struggles with heat retention and edge support. If you prioritize cooling and affordability, go with Loom & Leaf. If you’re all about that slow-sink Tempurpedic hug and don’t mind the price, Tempurpedic’s your pick. Let’s dive into the details to help you decide.
Compare the Models
| Feature | Loom & Leaf | Tempurpedic (TEMPUR-Cloud/ProAdapt) |
|---|---|---|
| Type | All-foam | All-foam or Hybrid (ProAdapt) |
| Firmness | Relaxed Firm (5.5), Firm (8) | Soft (3), Medium (5-6), Firm (7) |
| Height | 12 inches | 10-13 inches |
| Price (Queen) | $2,095 | $2,949-$4,599 |
| Trial Period | 365 nights | 90 nights |
| Warranty | 15 years | 10 years |
| Cooling | Excellent | Good (Breeze models better) |
| Sinkage | Deep (2.11”) | Minimal (1.46”) |
| Motion Transfer | Low | Very Low |
| Edge Support | Poor sitting, excellent lying | Poor sitting, mediocre lying |
| Bounce | Low (5.89”) | Very Low (4.47”-5.06”) |
Best Mattress For
- Side Sleepers: Loom & Leaf’s Relaxed Firm offers better cushioning for hips and shoulders, especially for those over 230 lbs. Tempurpedic’s softer models suit lighter side sleepers.
- Back Sleepers: Both work well, but Loom & Leaf’s Firm model provides stronger lumbar support for heavier folks.
- Stomach Sleepers: Loom & Leaf Firm or Tempurpedic Firm prevent hip sinkage, ideal for spinal alignment.
- Couples: Both excel at motion isolation, but Loom & Leaf’s cooling gives it an edge for hot-sleeping pairs.
- Hot Sleepers: Loom & Leaf’s gel-infused foam and breathable cover outperform Tempurpedic’s standard models.
- Heavy Sleepers: Loom & Leaf’s denser foams support up to 250+ lbs better than Tempurpedic’s softer options.
Performance Tests
We’ve analyzed data from sources like Sleepopolis to see how these mattresses stack up in key areas. Here’s the scoop.
Cooling Test
Loom & Leaf
Loom & Leaf tackles memory foam’s heat-trapping reputation head-on. Its gel-infused memory foam and organic cotton cover promote airflow, earning it an 8/10 for cooling. Testers noted no significant heat buildup after 15 minutes, making it a solid pick for hot sleepers.
Tempurpedic
Tempurpedic’s cooling varies by model. The TEMPUR-Cloud scores a 6.5/10, with noticeable heat retention after 15 minutes (peaking at 96.5°F). The Breeze models fare better, but they’re pricier. If you run hot, Tempurpedic might disappoint unless you splurge.
Sinkage Test
Loom & Leaf
With a 2.11-inch sinkage depth, Loom & Leaf offers a deep, cradling hug—43% more than the average mattress. This suits sleepers who love feeling enveloped but may feel restrictive for some.
Tempurpedic
Tempurpedic’s 1.46-inch sinkage is minimal, creating a “floating” feel rather than a deep hug. It’s great for those who prefer less contouring but may lack the cozy embrace some crave.
Motion Transfer Test
Loom & Leaf
Loom & Leaf scores a 9/10 for motion isolation, absorbing partner movements well (5.83 m/s², close to average). It’s ideal for couples with restless sleepers.
Tempurpedic
Tempurpedic edges out with a 9.5/10, showing even lower motion transfer (5.17 m/s²). You can practically jump on one side without waking your partner—perfect for light sleepers.
Response Test
Loom & Leaf
Loom & Leaf’s response time is slower than average at 0.9 seconds, typical for memory foam. It contours slowly, which may feel sluggish for combination sleepers.
Tempurpedic
Tempurpedic’s response is similarly slow (0.8 seconds for Cloud, 1 second for ProAdapt), aligning with its classic memory foam feel. Not ideal for quick position changes.
Bounce Test
Loom & Leaf
Bounce is low at 5.89 inches (48% of average), reducing motion transfer but making the bed feel less lively. This isn’t the mattress for bouncy fun.
Tempurpedic
Tempurpedic’s bounce is even lower (4.47-5.06 inches), emphasizing stability over responsiveness. It’s a calm, grounded sleep experience.
Edge Support Test
Loom & Leaf
Sitting edge support is weak (6.25 inches of sinkage, 2.22 inches more than average), but lying edge support is excellent, letting you use the full surface.
Tempurpedic
Tempurpedic struggles with both sitting (6 inches) and lying edge support, feeling unstable near the edges. You might feel like you’ll roll off.
Sex Test
Both mattresses score poorly for sex due to low bounce and weak edge support. Loom & Leaf (6/10) slightly outperforms Tempurpedic (5.5/10) thanks to better cooling and lying edge support, but neither is ideal for amorous activities.
Pressure Relief Test
Both excel here, scoring 9.5/10. Loom & Leaf’s thicker comfort layer (4.5 inches) edges out Tempurpedic (4 inches) for deeper contouring, especially for side sleepers.
Off-Gassing Test
Loom & Leaf has zero initial smell, arriving uncompressed with no off-gassing needed. Tempurpedic’s Cloud and ProAdapt have a mild chemical odor that fades in a few days, scoring 8/10.
Company
- Loom & Leaf (Saatva): Offers a 365-night trial, 15-year warranty, and free White Glove delivery (including old mattress removal). Returns incur a $99 fee. Customer service is top-notch.
- Tempurpedic: Provides a 90-night trial, 10-year warranty, and free shipping (but no White Glove). Returns are hassle-free but less flexible. Brand reputation is strong, but policies are less generous.
Firmness
Firmness affects comfort and support, so let’s break it down.
- Loom & Leaf – Relaxed Firm (5.5/10): Medium-firm, ideal for side and back sleepers seeking a balance of contour and support.
- Loom & Leaf – Firm (8/10): Firmer, great for stomach sleepers and heavier folks needing extra support.
- Tempurpedic – Medium (5-6/10): Medium to medium-firm, versatile for most sleepers but less supportive for heavier stomach sleepers.
- Tempurpedic – Medium Hybrid (6/10): Slightly firmer due to coils, good for back sleepers wanting responsiveness.
- Tempurpedic – Firm (7/10): Supports stomach and heavier sleepers but may feel too hard for lightweight side sleepers.
- Tempurpedic – Soft (3/10): Plush, best for lightweight side sleepers but lacks support for others.
Support & Sleeping Positions
- Loom & Leaf – Relaxed Firm: Great for side and back sleepers (130-230 lbs), with a gel-infused lumbar pad for spinal alignment.
- Loom & Leaf – Firm: Suits stomach sleepers and heavier folks (over 230 lbs) with denser foam for support.
- Tempurpedic – Medium: Best for side and back sleepers under 230 lbs, with excellent hip and shoulder relief.
- Tempurpedic – Medium Hybrid: Adds coil support for back sleepers but may lack for heavier folks.
- Tempurpedic – Firm: Ideal for stomach sleepers and heavier back sleepers, maintaining spinal alignment.
- Tempurpedic – Soft: Comfortable for lightweight side sleepers but not supportive for others.
Design
Both are all-foam (Tempurpedic offers hybrid options), focusing on memory foam’s contouring benefits. Loom & Leaf emphasizes cooling and durability with a high-density foam base, while Tempurpedic leans on its proprietary foam for a unique, slow-sinking feel. Loom & Leaf’s uncompressed shipping preserves foam integrity, while Tempurpedic’s boxed delivery is more compact but may off-gas.
Materials
Loom & Leaf
- Cover: Organic cotton, breathable and antimicrobial.
- Comfort Layer: 2” gel-infused memory foam (4 PCF), 2.5” memory foam (5 PCF), plus a gel lumbar pad.
- Transition Layer: 2” polyfoam.
- Support Core: 5.5” high-density polyfoam (1.8 PCF).
Tempurpedic
- Cover: Polyester, non-removable (Breeze models have cooling tech).
- Comfort Layer: 3-4” TEMPUR memory foam (varies by model).
- Support Core: 7-9” support foam or pocketed coils (hybrid).
Loom & Leaf vs. Tempurpedic
Should You Buy the Loom & Leaf?
Yes, if you:
- Want a luxury memory foam mattress for less ($2,095 vs. $4,599 for Tempurpedic’s ProAdapt).
- Run hot and need better cooling.
- Prefer deeper sinkage and a cozy, hugging feel.
- Value a longer trial (365 nights) and White Glove delivery.
- Need versatility for heavier sleepers or multiple sleeping positions.
Skip it if:
- You want a bouncy, responsive bed (consider a hybrid like Saatva Classic).
- You need top-tier edge support for sitting.
Should You Buy the Tempurpedic?
Yes, if you:
- Love Tempurpedic’s signature slow-sinking, cradling feel.
- Prioritize minimal motion transfer for undisturbed sleep.
- Are a lightweight side sleeper (under 230 lbs) or loyal to the brand.
- Don’t mind paying a premium for brand prestige.
Skip it if:
- You sleep hot and can’t afford the Breeze models.
- You need strong edge support or bounce.
- You want a longer trial period or lower price.
FAQ
Q: Which mattress is better for hot sleepers?
A: Loom & Leaf, thanks to its gel-infused foam and breathable cover, outperforms Tempurpedic’s standard models.
Q: How do their prices compare?
A: Loom & Leaf is more affordable ($2,095 for a queen) compared to Tempurpedic ($2,949-$4,599).
Q: Can I flip these mattresses?
A: No, both are single-sided and not designed to be flipped.
Q: Which has a better trial period?
A: Loom & Leaf’s 365-night trial beats Tempurpedic’s 90 nights.
Q: Are these good for couples?
A: Yes, both isolate motion well, but Loom & Leaf’s cooling makes it better for hot-sleeping couples.
There you have it, folks! The Loom & Leaf and Tempurpedic are both stellar memory foam mattresses, but your choice depends on your priorities. For cooling, value, and versatility, Loom & Leaf takes the crown. For that iconic Tempurpedic hug and top-notch motion isolation, Tempurpedic delivers. Head to Mattressnap for more reviews, and sweet dreams!
