Hey there, mattress shoppers! If you’re on the hunt for the perfect coil mattress, you’re in the right place. Coil mattresses, also known as innerspring or hybrid mattresses, have been a staple in bedrooms for decades, and for good reason. They offer that classic bouncy feel, excellent support, and breathability that keeps you cool all night.
But with so many options out there, how do you pick the best one? I’ve scoured the web, dug into expert reviews, and analyzed customer feedback to bring you an in-depth look at the best coil mattresses of 2025. Let’s break it down, chat about what makes these beds stand out, and help you find the one that’ll give you the sleep of your dreams.
What Makes a Coil Mattress Great?
Before we dive into the top picks, let’s talk about why coil mattresses are so popular. Unlike all-foam beds, coil mattresses use a system of metal springs (or coils) to provide support. These coils are often paired with foam or latex layers for added comfort, making most modern coil mattresses hybrids. Here’s what makes them awesome:
- Support and Bounce: Coils provide a sturdy foundation that keeps your spine aligned and gives that springy feel many sleepers love.
- Breathability: The spaces between coils allow air to circulate, making these beds cooler than memory foam.
- Durability: High-quality coil systems can last 8–10 years or more.
- Versatility: With various firmness options, they suit side, back, stomach, and combination sleepers.
But not all coil mattresses are created equal. The best ones use pocketed coils (individually wrapped springs) for better motion isolation and contouring, and they balance comfort layers to avoid that “sleeping on springs” feel. Now, let’s get to the good stuff: the top coil mattresses of 2025 based on expert tests and real-world reviews.
Top 5 Coil Mattresses of 2025
1. Saatva Classic – Best Overall Coil Mattress
Price: ~$1,795 for a queen
Firmness: Plush Soft (5/10), Luxury Firm (7/10), Firm (9/10)
Trial Period: 365 nights
Warranty: Lifetime
Why It’s Great:
The Saatva Classic is the gold standard for coil mattresses, and it’s easy to see why. This luxury hybrid combines two coil layers—a pocketed coil top layer for cushioning and a supportive interconnected coil base—for a “Goldilocks” balance of comfort and support. Reviewers at Sleep Advisor call it a “luxury bed at a decent price,” praising its ability to suit nearly every sleeper.
- Comfort and Support: The 3-inch Euro pillow top feels plush yet supportive, with a firmer middle third to cradle your lower back. Testers at Business Insider noted it promotes spinal alignment, making it ideal for back pain sufferers. Customer reviews (over 67,000 surveyed by Consumer Reports) highlight its comfort across sleeping positions.
- Cooling: Organic cotton and pocketed coils keep it breezy, perfect for hot sleepers.
- Edge Support: Reinforced coils around the perimeter make it sturdy for sitting or sleeping near the edge, a big plus for couples.
- White Glove Delivery: Unlike most bed-in-a-box brands, Saatva offers free in-home setup and old mattress removal.
What We Don’t Like:
- Motion transfer isn’t perfect. Wirecutter notes the lower coil layer isn’t pocketed, so you might feel your partner’s movements.
- Returns cost $99, which is a bummer compared to free returns from other brands.
- It’s pricier than budget options, though the quality justifies the cost.
Who It’s For: Side, back, or stomach sleepers who want a luxurious, supportive bed with multiple firmness options. It’s especially great for back pain relief and those who value premium service.
2. WinkBed – Best for Back Pain
Price: ~$1,499 for a queen
Firmness: Softer (4/10), Luxury Firm (6/10), Firm (7/10), Plus (for heavier sleepers)
Trial Period: 120 nights
Warranty: Lifetime
Why It’s Great:
The WinkBed is a powerhouse hybrid that’s a favorite for back pain sufferers. Its zoned pocketed coil system uses thicker coils under your midsection for lumbar support and thinner coils at the head and feet for cradling. Sleep Foundation reports that 8,573 customer reviews praise its pain relief, with many noting less back, hip, and shoulder discomfort.
- Supportive Design: The three-zone coil system ensures your spine stays aligned, earning it a 9.4/10 performance score from Sleepline. Testers at Naplab gave it a 9.82/10, the highest among hybrids, for its balance of sinkage and bounce.
- Breathability: A Tencel cover and gel-infused foam keep it cool, ideal for hot sleepers.
- Edge Support: Reinforced perimeter coils make it feel stable, even when you’re near the edge.
- Firmness Options: With four choices, including a Plus model for heavier folks (over 250 lbs), it’s highly customizable.
What We Don’t Like:
- Motion isolation is average. Sleepline gave it an 8.9/10 for motion transfer, so light sleepers might feel their partner’s movements.
- It’s a bit heavy, making it tricky to move without help.
- The price is higher than budget brands, though discounts (like 25% off with code MEMORIAL25) help.
Who It’s For: Back pain sufferers, hot sleepers, and those who want a durable, customizable bed. The Plus model is a standout for heavier individuals.
3. Helix Midnight Luxe – Best for Side Sleepers
Price: ~$1,899 for a queen
Firmness: Medium-Firm (6.5/10)
Trial Period: 100 nights
Warranty: 15 years
Why It’s Great:
Side sleepers, rejoice! The Helix Midnight Luxe is designed with you in mind, offering plush comfort that cradles your shoulders and hips. Sleepopolis testers loved its pressure-relieving foam layers and sturdy coils, with pressure map tests showing low pressure points for side and back sleepers. Forbes gave it high marks for cooling and support after over a year of testing.
- Pressure Relief: The pillow top and memory foam layers contour without making you feel stuck, earning a 4.7/5 from Sleepopolis.
- Cooling: Copper infusions and pocketed coils promote airflow, a boon for hot sleepers.
- Motion Isolation: It scores high for couples, with minimal motion transfer, per Forbes testers.
- Customization: Helix’s sleep quiz helps you pick the right model based on your preferences.
What We Don’t Like:
- It’s not ideal for stomach sleepers, as it’s too soft for proper spinal alignment.
- The foam layers make it harder to move around, which could bother combination sleepers.
- It’s on the pricier side, though discounts like 20% off with code SUMMER20 help.
Who It’s For: Side sleepers under 230 lbs, couples, and hot sleepers who want a cushy yet supportive bed.
4. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid – Best Budget Coil Mattress
Price: ~$850 for a queen (with discounts)
Firmness: Soft, Medium, Firm
Trial Period: 120 nights
Warranty: Lifetime
Why It’s Great:
If you’re looking for value without sacrificing quality, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is a steal. This hybrid combines pocketed coils with foam layers for a balanced feel that suits most sleepers. Sleep Foundation praises its affordability and versatility, with free shipping and a lifetime warranty sweetening the deal.
- Affordable Quality: At under $1,000 (with discounts like 25% off with code MEMORIAL25), it rivals pricier beds in comfort and durability.
- Versatility: Available in three firmness levels, it works for side, back, and combination sleepers.
- Cooling: A breathable cotton cover and coils keep it airy.
- Edge Support: Thicker perimeter coils make it sturdy for sitting or sleeping near the edge.
What We Don’t Like:
- Motion isolation isn’t top-notch, so couples might feel some movement.
- The optional “Cloud” pillow top adds cost and may soften the feel too much for some.
- It’s less luxurious than premium brands like Saatva or WinkBed.
Who It’s For: Budget-conscious shoppers, combination sleepers, and those who want a reliable hybrid with solid support.
5. Avocado Organic Luxury Plush – Best Eco-Friendly Coil Mattress
Price: ~$2,499 for a queen
Firmness: Medium, Plush, Ultra Plush
Trial Period: 365 nights
Warranty: 25 years
Why It’s Great:
For eco-conscious sleepers, the Avocado Organic Luxury Plush is a dream come true. This 17-layer hybrid uses organic latex, wool, silk, cotton, and 1,379 pocketed coils for a luxurious, sustainable sleep experience. CNET and Good Housekeeping praise its sustainability certifications (like GOTS and Greenguard Gold) and pressure-relieving design.
- Sustainability: Made without harmful chemicals, it’s a Consumer Reports Green Choice pick.
- Comfort: Seven ergonomic zones relieve pressure, especially for side sleepers, per CNET.
- Durability: Hand-tufted layers and a 25-year warranty ensure long-lasting quality.
- Cooling: Organic materials and coils promote airflow for a cool night’s sleep.
What We Don’t Like:
- It’s expensive, with plush models adding $800–$1,600 to the cost.
- Motion isolation is good but not as strong as foam-heavy hybrids.
- It’s heavy, making setup a two-person job.
Who It’s For: Eco-conscious sleepers, side sleepers, and those who want a premium, durable mattress with a long trial period.
How We Picked These Mattresses
To find the best coil mattresses, I leaned on reviews from trusted sources like Sleep Foundation, Forbes Vetted, Wirecutter, Sleepopolis, Good Housekeeping, and CNET. These sites use rigorous testing methods, including:
- Pressure Mapping: To assess how well mattresses relieve pressure points.
- Motion Transfer Tests: To check if movement disturbs a partner.
- Edge Support Tests: To evaluate stability near the edges.
- Cooling Tests: To measure breathability.
- Durability Tests: To ensure long-term performance.
I also considered customer feedback (e.g., Sleep Foundation’s meta-analysis of thousands of reviews) and prioritized mattresses with high scores for comfort, support, and value. Finally, I looked at warranties, trial periods, and brand reputation to ensure you’re getting a reliable product.
What to Consider When Buying a Coil Mattress
Choosing the right coil mattress comes down to a few key factors. Here’s what to keep in mind:
- Coil Type:
- Firmness:
- Side sleepers: Medium to soft (4–6/10) for pressure relief.
- Back/stomach sleepers: Medium to firm (6–9/10) for spinal alignment.
- Combination sleepers: Medium (5–7/10) for versatility.
- Comfort Layers: Foam, latex, or pillow tops add cushioning. Look for breathable materials like latex or gel-infused foam if you sleep hot.
- Edge Support: Reinforced coils around the perimeter prevent sagging, crucial for couples or those who sit on the bed’s edge.
- Trial and Warranty: A 100+ night trial and 10+ year warranty give peace of mind. Saatva and Avocado offer 365-night trials, while WinkBed and Brooklyn Bedding provide lifetime warranties.
- Budget: Prices range from $850 (Brooklyn Bedding) to $2,500 (Avocado). Discounts are common, so check for promo codes.
Common Complaints and How Top Picks Address Them
Coil mattresses aren’t perfect, and reviews highlight a few recurring issues. Here’s how our top picks tackle them:
- Motion Transfer: Innersprings can be bouncy, disturbing light sleepers. Helix Midnight Luxe and Avocado excel in motion isolation thanks to pocketed coils and foam layers.
- Sagging: Cheaper coils may sag over time. WinkBed and Saatva use high-gauge, tempered steel coils for durability, backed by lifetime warranties.
- Price: Premium hybrids can be costly. Brooklyn Bedding offers similar quality at a lower price point.
- Firmness Mismatch: Some find their mattress too soft or firm. Saatva and WinkBed offer multiple firmness options to suit different preferences.
Final Thoughts: Which Coil Mattress Is Right for You?
After diving deep into reviews and testing data, it’s clear that the best coil mattress depends on your needs and budget. Here’s a quick recap to help you decide:
- Saatva Classic: The all-around champ for luxury, support, and versatility. Perfect if you want a premium bed with free setup.
- WinkBed: A lifesaver for back pain and heavier sleepers, with excellent support and customization.
- Helix Midnight Luxe: The go-to for side sleepers and couples, with plush comfort and great motion isolation.
- Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid: The budget-friendly pick that doesn’t skimp on quality.
- Avocado Organic Luxury Plush: The eco-warrior’s dream, blending sustainability with luxury.
No matter which you choose, these mattresses are backed by rigorous testing and glowing reviews. So, take advantage of those generous trial periods, test out your new bed, and get ready for some seriously restful nights. Sweet dreams!
