Welcome to Mattressnap, your go-to source for honest, in-depth mattress reviews! If you’re dreaming of a bed that feels like sinking into a cloud while still cradling your body with support, you’re in for a treat.
Soft mattresses are a game-changer for side sleepers, lightweight folks, or anyone who loves that plush, cozy embrace. But with countless options out there, finding the perfect one can feel overwhelming.
That’s why we’ve done the heavy lifting—scouring expert reviews, analyzing performance data, and diving into real-world feedback to bring you the top seven soft mattresses for 2025. From cooling tech to pressure relief, we’ll break down what makes each mattress shine, who it’s best for, and any quirks to watch out for. Let’s get cozy and dive in!
Mattressnap’s Top Pick: WinkBed Mattress
At Mattressnap, we’re crowning the WinkBed as the best soft mattress of 2025. Its perfect blend of plush comfort, robust support, and all-around versatility makes it a standout for nearly every sleeper. Whether you’re a side sleeper craving pressure relief or a back sleeper needing spinal alignment, the WinkBed’s soft version (rated 4/10 on firmness) delivers big time.
The 7 Best Soft Mattresses, Mattressnap-Approved
Here’s our handpicked list of the seven best soft mattresses, each excelling in specific areas. We’ll walk you through their strengths, who they’re ideal for, key performance metrics, and any considerations to keep in mind. Let’s find your dream bed!
1. WinkBed Mattress
Best For
- Side sleepers needing cushioning for shoulders and hips.
- Back sleepers wanting lumbar support without a firm feel.
- Hot sleepers looking for a breathable, cool sleep surface.
- Couples seeking low motion transfer and excellent edge support.
Considerations
- Price: A queen runs about $1,499, making it a premium choice.
- Motion transfer: Great for most couples, but ultra-light sleepers might notice slight movement.
- Setup: Its hybrid design is heavy, so plan for a two-person setup.
Mattressnap’s Verdict
The WinkBed’s soft version is a luxury hybrid that nails the balance of cloud-like comfort and sturdy support. Its Euro-top design paired with pocketed coils creates a responsive, bouncy feel that’s easy to move on, while the Tencel cover keeps you cool all night. With a 120-night trial and lifetime warranty, it’s a low-risk pick for premium sleep. At Mattressnap, we love its versatility for a wide range of sleepers.
WinkBed Performance
- Cooling Test: Top 1% for heat dissipation, thanks to a breathable Tencel cover and airy coil system.
- Sinkage Test: Moderate 2.1-inch sinkage for a cradling feel without trapping you.
- Motion Transfer Test: 47% below average, ideal for couples but not perfect for the most sensitive sleepers.
- Response Test: Lightning-fast response for easy position changes.
- Bounce Test: High 10.5-inch bounce for a lively, responsive vibe.
- Edge Support Test: Stellar edge support, perfect for sitting or sleeping near the edge.
2. Saatva Classic
Best For
- Back pain sufferers needing targeted lumbar support.
- Stomach sleepers wanting a plush yet supportive surface.
- Hot sleepers who love a classic innerspring feel.
- Luxury seekers who appreciate white-glove delivery.
Considerations
- Price: A queen costs $1,795, about 30% above average.
- Firmness: The Plush Soft (3.5/10) might feel too firm for those seeking a true “cloud-like” sink.
- Motion transfer: Coils mean slightly more motion than foam-heavy hybrids.
Mattressnap’s Verdict
The Saatva Classic’s Plush Soft option is a luxurious innerspring hybrid with a Euro-top cover and dual-coil system. Scoring an impressive 9.74/10, it’s a top performer for pressure relief and spinal alignment—perfect for back pain sufferers. Free white-glove delivery and a 365-night trial make it a Mattressnap favorite for those wanting a high-end experience.
Saatva Performance
- Cooling Test: Dual coils promote strong airflow, ranking in the top 1% for temperature regulation.
- Sinkage Test: Deep 2.5-inch sinkage for a cozy, contouring feel.
- Motion Transfer Test: Decent for a coil mattress, but foam hybrids edge it out.
- Response Test: Highly responsive, ideal for combination sleepers.
- Bounce Test: Springy 11-inch bounce for a lively feel.
- Edge Support Test: Rock-solid edge support, great for couples and edge-sitters.
3. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
Best For
- Hot sleepers needing best-in-class cooling.
- Side sleepers with hip or shoulder pain.
- Couples prioritizing edge support and motion isolation.
- Sleepers wanting options (Soft, Medium, Firm).
Considerations
- Price: $1,699 for a queen, 23% above average.
- Sinkage: Moderate 2.0-inch sinkage may not satisfy deep-contouring fans.
- Adjustable bases: Less ideal for adjustable frames due to its firm hybrid build.
Mattressnap’s Verdict
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe (Soft, 4/10) is a cooling superstar with its GlacioTex cover and breathable coils. Scoring 9.33/10, it’s a top 5% mattress and a Mattressnap go-to for side sleepers with joint pain. Its balanced pressure relief and support make it a fantastic all-around pick.
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Performance
- Cooling Test: Elite cooling performance, rivaling the best for hot sleepers.
- Sinkage Test: Moderate sinkage for comfort and easy movement.
- Motion Transfer Test: Solid motion isolation, great for couples.
- Response Test: Quick response for seamless position changes.
- Bounce Test: Balanced 9-inch bounce for a lively yet controlled feel.
- Edge Support Test: Strong edge support to maximize bed space.
4. Nolah Evolution 15
Best For
- Side sleepers needing zoned support for pressure points.
- Lightweight sleepers under 130 pounds.
- Hot sleepers wanting a foam-heavy hybrid.
- Couples seeking minimal motion transfer.
Considerations
- Price: $1,424 for a queen, slightly above average.
- Edge support: Weaker than coil-heavy hybrids like Saatva.
- Heavy sleepers: May feel too soft for those over 230 pounds.
Mattressnap’s Verdict
The Nolah Evolution 15 (Soft, 4/10) is a plush hybrid with a thick foam layer and zoned coils for targeted support. Its 9.28/10 score ranks it in the top 7% of mattresses, making it a Mattressnap favorite for side sleepers. A 120-night trial and lifetime warranty seal the deal.
Nolah Performance
- Cooling Test: Good cooling with breathable foams, though not as strong as Aurora Luxe.
- Sinkage Test: Deep 2.48-inch sinkage for a cradling hug.
- Motion Transfer Test: Excellent motion isolation for couples.
- Response Test: Fast response for easy movement.
- Bounce Test: Moderate 8.72-inch bounce for a balanced feel.
- Edge Support Test: Decent but not standout edge support.
5. Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid
Best For
- Lightweight side sleepers craving a memory foam hug.
- Hot sleepers needing a cooling cover.
- Sleepers wanting one firmness (extra soft, 3.5/10).
- Joint pain sufferers seeking deep pressure relief.
Considerations
- Price: $2,199 for a queen, 48% above average.
- Motion transfer: Higher than average, not ideal for light-sleeping couples.
- Heavy sleepers: Too soft for those over 230 pounds.
Mattressnap’s Verdict
The Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid (3.5/10) is the softest on our list, with a memory foam layer that hugs like a dream. Scoring 9.24/10, it’s a top 10% mattress and a Mattressnap pick for lightweight side sleepers. Its cooling cover is a standout for hot sleepers.
Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid Performance
- Cooling Test: Excellent cooling with a chilly cover.
- Sinkage Test: Moderate 2.21-inch sinkage for a soft yet mobile feel.
- Motion Transfer Test: Higher motion transfer, a downside for couples.
- Response Test: Ultra-fast response for great mobility.
- Bounce Test: Surprising 9.71-inch bounce for a soft mattress.
- Edge Support Test: Solid edge support with zoned coils.
6. Bear Elite Hybrid
Best For
- Side sleepers with back or joint pain.
- Couples needing low motion transfer.
- Hot sleepers wanting a cooling cover.
- Sleepers wanting options (Soft, Medium, Firm).
Considerations
- Price: $1,614 for a queen, 4% above average.
- Sinkage: Moderate sinkage may not satisfy deep-contouring lovers.
- Heavy sleepers: Soft version may lack support for those over 230 pounds.
Mattressnap’s Verdict
The Bear Elite Hybrid (Soft, 4.5/10) blends memory foam and coil support, earning a 9.24/10 score. It’s a Mattressnap favorite for side sleepers with back pain, offering great pressure relief and cooling. A 120-night trial and lifetime warranty add value.
Bear Elite Performance
- Cooling Test: Elite cooling with a phase-change cover.
- Sinkage Test: Moderate 2.0-inch sinkage for balanced comfort.
- Motion Transfer Test: Low motion transfer, perfect for couples.
- Response Test: Quick response for easy position switches.
- Bounce Test: High 10-inch bounce for a lively feel.
- Edge Support Test: Strong edge support for edge sleepers.
7. Leesa Sapira Chill
Best For
- All sleeping positions with three firmness options.
- Hot sleepers needing advanced cooling.
- Couples wanting strong edge support and motion isolation.
- Side sleepers under 130 pounds (medium model).
Considerations
- Price: $1,699 for a queen, 25% above average.
- Responsiveness: Foam layers may feel sticky for some.
- Off-gassing: Slight odor for the first few days.
Mattressnap’s Verdict
The Leesa Sapira Chill (Medium, 5/10) is a versatile hybrid with a plush, cooling cover and zoned coils. Its 9.48/10 score ranks it in the top 2% of mattresses, making it a Mattressnap standout for pressure relief and cooling. A 100-night trial and lifetime warranty make it a safe bet.
Leesa Sapira Chill Performance
- Cooling Test: Excellent cooling with a 6.3-degree temp rise after 5 minutes.
- Sinkage Test: Moderate 2.0-inch sinkage for balanced comfort.
- Motion Transfer Test: Good motion isolation, though not the best.
- Response Test: Slightly slower response due to foam layers.
- Bounce Test: High 10-inch bounce for great mobility.
- Edge Support Test: Strong edge support for couples.
How Mattressnap Chose These Mattresses
At Mattressnap, we’re obsessed with finding the best beds for every sleeper. To build this list, we analyzed expert reviews from trusted sources like NapLab, Sleepopolis, Sleep Foundation, and Forbes Vetted, who tested over 320 mattresses. We focused on:
- Firmness: A soft feel (3.5–5/10) for that plush vibe.
- Pressure Relief: Essential for side sleepers and joint pain relief.
- Cooling: Critical for hot sleepers, evaluated via heat dissipation and cover tech.
- Motion Transfer: Key for couples, measured with objective tests.
- Edge Support: Maximizes bed space and ease of movement.
- Bounce and Response: Impacts mobility and overall feel.
- Price vs. Performance: Ensures value for your budget.
We prioritized mattresses with high performance scores (9.2+), multiple firmness options (where applicable), and strong user feedback. Each mattress was vetted for real-world suitability across sleep styles, body types, and preferences to earn the Mattressnap seal of approval.
Who Should Choose a Soft Mattress?
Soft mattresses are perfect for:
- Side sleepers: Plush surfaces cushion shoulders and hips, easing pressure points.
- Lightweight sleepers (<130 pounds): Softer beds contour better to smaller frames.
- Joint pain sufferers: Deep pressure relief soothes discomfort.
- Hot sleepers: Many soft hybrids now boast cooling tech.
- Couples: Low motion transfer and strong edge support improve shared sleep.
Soft mattresses may not be ideal for:
- Heavy sleepers (>230 pounds): Risk of sinking too deeply, misaligning the spine.
- Stomach sleepers: Softer beds can cause hips to dip, straining the back.
- Budget shoppers: Premium soft mattresses often come with a higher price.
Mattressnap’s Final Take
Picking the perfect soft mattress is all about your sleep style, body type, and priorities. The WinkBed is Mattressnap’s top pick for its unmatched versatility, cooling, and support—a true all-rounder. For luxury and back pain relief, the Saatva Classic is a close second.
Hot sleepers will love the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe, while the Nolah Evolution 15 and Bear Elite Hybrid are side-sleeper favorites. The Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid is ideal for memory foam lovers, and the Leesa Sapira Chill suits nearly everyone with its balanced feel.
