Choosing the perfect mattress can feel like a big decision, especially when you’re torn between two popular hybrid options like the WinkBed and DreamCloud. Both brands have earned praise for their comfort, support, and value, but they cater to slightly different sleepers.
In this in-depth comparison of Mattressnap, we’ll break down the key differences, analyze performance tests, and help you decide which mattress is right for you. Let’s dive in with a conversational, easy-to-read guide that covers everything from cooling to construction.
WinkBed
The WinkBed is a luxury hybrid mattress made in the USA, known for its customizable firmness options and high-quality materials. It’s designed to offer a balance of plush comfort and robust support, making it a favorite for those who want a hotel-like sleep experience. With four firmness levels—Softer, Luxury Firm, Firmer, and Plus—it’s versatile enough to suit a wide range of sleepers.
Best For
- Side sleepers who need pressure relief (Softer model).
- Back and stomach sleepers seeking firm support (Luxury Firm or Firmer).
- Heavyweight sleepers (Plus model, designed for 250+ lbs).
- Hot sleepers looking for excellent airflow.
- Combination sleepers who change positions often.
DreamCloud
DreamCloud offers a lineup of luxury hybrid mattresses, including the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid, DreamCloud Premier, and DreamCloud Premier Rest. Known for their affordability and plush comfort, these mattresses combine memory foam and coils for a supportive yet cushy feel. With a single firmness option per model, DreamCloud appeals to those who want a straightforward, budget-friendly choice.
Best For
- Back sleepers who need spinal alignment.
- Hot sleepers seeking cooling features.
- Budget shoppers looking for luxury at a lower price.
- Seniors who want easy mobility.
- Couples who prefer minimal motion transfer.
Our Verdict
Both WinkBed and DreamCloud deliver exceptional hybrid mattresses, but they shine in different areas. WinkBed is the winner for sleepers who value customization, with four firmness options to match specific needs, plus superior edge support and responsiveness.
DreamCloud takes the lead for budget-conscious buyers, offering a plush, supportive feel at a lower price point, with excellent cooling and motion isolation. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize versatility (WinkBed) or value (DreamCloud).
Performance Tests
WinkBed vs. DreamCloud: Which Is the Winner?
In head-to-head performance tests, WinkBed often edges out DreamCloud due to its superior cooling, faster response time, and better edge support. However, DreamCloud holds its own with strong bounce and value, especially in the Premier model. Let’s break it down by category.
Cooling Test
Both mattresses are hybrids, which naturally sleep cooler than all-foam beds due to their coil layers. However, their cooling performance varies.
DreamCloud Cooling Test
DreamCloud mattresses use gel-infused memory foam and breathable cashmere-blend covers to promote airflow. The Luxury Hybrid and Premier models sleep slightly cooler than average, while the Premier Rest’s thicker foam layers retain a bit more heat.
WinkBed Luxury Firm Cooling Test
The WinkBed Luxury Firm excels in cooling, thanks to its Tencel cover and gel-infused foam pillow top. Testers at Mattressnap noted that it dissipates heat faster than DreamCloud, maintaining a cooler surface even after prolonged use.
DreamCloud Premier Cooling Test
The Premier offers solid cooling, slightly better than the Luxury Hybrid, but it doesn’t match WinkBed’s heat dissipation. It’s a great choice for hot sleepers on a budget.
WinkBed Soft Cooling Test
The Softer WinkBed model retains slightly more heat due to its plush pillow top but still outperforms most DreamCloud models in thermal regulation.
DreamCloud Premier Rest Cooling Test
The Premier Rest, with its 16-inch profile and thicker foam layers, is the warmest of the DreamCloud lineup. It’s still breathable for a hybrid but lags behind WinkBed.
WinkBed Plus Cooling Test
The Plus model, designed for heavier sleepers, maintains excellent airflow, making it ideal for those who overheat.
Winner: WinkBed, for consistently better heat dissipation across all models.
Sinkage Test
Sinkage measures how deeply you sink into a mattress, affecting comfort and ease of movement. The average sinkage across mattresses is about 2.2 inches.
DreamCloud
The DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid has deeper sinkage (around 2.5 inches), offering a cozy, contouring feel.
WinkBed Luxury Firm
The Luxury Firm has moderate sinkage (2.3 inches), balancing support and cushioning.
DreamCloud Premier
The Premier has less sinkage (around 2.0 inches), making it feel more supportive and less “huggy.”
WinkBed Soft
The Softer WinkBed has deeper sinkage (2.6 inches), ideal for side sleepers who want to sink in for pressure relief.
DreamCloud Premier Rest
The Premier Rest also has minimal sinkage (2.0 inches), despite its plush pillow top.
WinkBed Plus
The Plus model has moderate sinkage (2.3 inches), designed to support heavier bodies without excessive sinking.
Winner: Tie. DreamCloud Premier and Premier Rest offer less sinkage for a firmer feel, while WinkBed’s range caters to varied preferences.
Motion Transfer
Motion transfer is crucial for couples, as it determines how much movement from one partner disturbs the other. Lower scores (in m/s²) indicate better isolation.
DreamCloud Motion Transfer
The Luxury Hybrid scores around 5.8 m/s², close to the average, with solid motion isolation due to its memory foam layer.
WinkBed Luxury Firm Motion Transfer
The Luxury Firm scores similarly (5.8 m/s²), but it’s not as isolating as softer models.
DreamCloud Premier Motion Transfer
The Premier performs well (5.5 m/s²), slightly better than the Luxury Hybrid.
WinkBed Soft Motion Transfer
The Softer WinkBed has higher motion transfer (6.5 m/s²), making it less ideal for couples.
DreamCloud Premier Rest Motion Transfer
The Premier Rest shines with low motion transfer (5.0 m/s²), thanks to its thicker foam layers.
WinkBed Plus Motion Transfer
The Plus model scores poorly (6.8 m/s²), as its firmer structure amplifies motion.
Winner: DreamCloud Premier Rest, for the best motion isolation among all models.
Response Test
Response time measures how quickly a mattress adjusts to your movements, affecting ease of position changes.
DreamCloud Response Test
The Luxury Hybrid has a slower response (around 0.8 seconds), typical of memory foam hybrids.
WinkBed Luxury Firm Response Test
The Luxury Firm responds faster (0.4 seconds), making it more responsive for combination sleepers.
DreamCloud Premier Response Test
The Premier is slightly faster (0.7 seconds) than the Luxury Hybrid but still lags behind WinkBed.
WinkBed Soft Response Test
The Softer model responds quickly (0.5 seconds), despite its plush feel.
DreamCloud Premier Rest Response Test
The Premier Rest is the slowest (0.9 seconds) due to its thicker foam layers.
WinkBed Plus Response Test
The Plus model matches the Luxury Firm’s fast response (0.4 seconds).
Winner: WinkBed, for consistently faster response times across all models.
Bounce Test
Bounce affects mobility and can influence intimacy. Higher bounce is better for combination sleepers and sex.
DreamCloud Bounce Test
The Luxury Hybrid has high bounce (10 inches), ideal for mobility.
WinkBed Luxury Firm Bounce Test
The Luxury Firm has moderate bounce (9 inches), slightly less than DreamCloud.
DreamCloud Premier Bounce Test
The Premier matches the Luxury Hybrid’s high bounce (10 inches).
WinkBed Soft Bounce Test
The Softer model has lower bounce (8 inches), prioritizing cushioning.
DreamCloud Premier Rest Bounce Test
The Premier Rest has moderate bounce (9 inches).
WinkBed Plus Bounce Test
The Plus model has high bounce (10 inches), supporting heavier sleepers.
Winner: DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid and Premier, for the highest bounce.
Edge Support Test
Edge support determines how stable the mattress feels near the edges, crucial for couples and those who sleep close to the side.
DreamCloud
The Luxury Hybrid has decent edge support but compresses more than WinkBed.
WinkBed Luxury Firm
The Luxury Firm excels with reinforced coils, offering minimal compression.
DreamCloud Premier
The Premier improves slightly over the Luxury Hybrid but still trails WinkBed.
WinkBed Soft
The Softer model has weaker edge support due to its plush design.
DreamCloud Premier Rest
The Premier Rest matches the Premier’s edge support, adequate but not outstanding.
WinkBed Plus
The Plus model offers excellent edge support, ideal for heavier sleepers.
Winner: WinkBed Luxury Firm and Plus, for superior edge support.
Sex Test
For intimacy, mattresses need high bounce, good edge support, and responsiveness. WinkBed scores higher overall due to its fast response and edge support, though DreamCloud’s bounce is a strong point.
Winner: WinkBed.
Pressure Relief Test
Pressure relief is key for side sleepers and those with joint pain.
- DreamCloud: The Luxury Hybrid and Premier (7/10 firmness) offer good pressure relief for back sleepers but may be too firm for strict side sleepers. The Premier Rest (6.5/10) is better for side sleepers.
- WinkBed: The Softer model (4/10) excels for side sleepers, while the Luxury Firm (6/10) and Firmer (7/10) suit back and stomach sleepers. The Plus (7/10) supports heavier bodies.
Winner: WinkBed, for its range of firmness options catering to different needs.
Off-Gassing Test
Both mattresses have minimal off-gassing, with odors dissipating within a day or two due to their hybrid construction.
Winner: Tie.
Company
- DreamCloud: Offers a 365-night trial, lifetime warranty, and free shipping. White glove delivery is available for a fee.
- WinkBed: Provides a 120-night trial, lifetime warranty, and free shipping. Made-to-order in the USA, ensuring fresh materials.
Winner: DreamCloud, for its longer trial period.
Firmness
- DreamCloud: The Luxury Hybrid and Premier are firm (7/10), while the Premier Rest is medium-firm (6.5/10).
- WinkBed: Offers Softer (4/10), Luxury Firm (6/10), Firmer (7/10), and Plus (7/10), catering to a wide range of preferences.
Winner: WinkBed, for its customizable firmness options.
Support & Sleeping Positions
- DreamCloud: Best for back sleepers and some combination sleepers. The Luxury Hybrid and Premier are too firm for strict side sleepers, while the Premier Rest suits lighter side sleepers. Back sleepers under 230 lbs and stomach sleepers under 130 lbs find good support.
- WinkBed: Accommodates all sleeping positions. The Softer model is ideal for side sleepers, Luxury Firm and Firmer for back and stomach sleepers, and Plus for heavier sleepers (250+ lbs).
Winner: WinkBed, for broader support across sleep styles and body types.
Design
DreamCloud
DreamCloud mattresses are bed-in-a-box hybrids with a cashmere-blend cover, gel-infused memory foam, and pocketed coils. The Luxury Hybrid and Premier are 14 inches tall, while the Premier Rest is 16 inches.
WinkBed
WinkBed is a made-to-order hybrid with a Tencel cover, gel-infused foam pillow top, and zoned pocketed coils. All models are 13.5 inches tall, with a focus on durability and craftsmanship.
Winner: WinkBed, for its made-to-order quality and premium design.
Materials
DreamCloud
- Luxury Hybrid: Cashmere-blend cover, 1.5” quilted foam, 1” gel memory foam, 2.5” support foam, 8” pocketed coils, 1” firm foam base.
- Premier: Similar to Luxury Hybrid but with a slightly plusher top layer.
- Premier Rest: Adds a pillow top for a 16-inch profile, with thicker foam layers.
WinkBed
- Luxury Firm: Tencel cover, 1” hypersoft foam, 1” gel foam, 2.4” micro air-spring coils, lumbar pad, 8” pocketed coils, 2” support foam.
- Softer: Thicker pillow top for a plusher feel.
- Plus: Firmer coils and denser foam for heavier sleepers.
Winner: WinkBed, for its zoned coil system and premium materials.
Which Mattress Should You Buy?
Should You Buy the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid?
- You’re on a budget but want a luxury feel.
- You’re a back sleeper or combination sleeper.
- You sleep hot and need good cooling.
- You prefer a firmer mattress (7/10).
Should You Buy the WinkBed Luxury Firm?
- You want a balanced medium-firm feel (6/10).
- You’re a back or stomach sleeper.
- You need excellent edge support for sharing a bed.
- You value made-in-USA quality.
Should You Buy the DreamCloud Premier?
- You want a slightly plusher feel than the Luxury Hybrid.
- You’re a back sleeper or lightweight side sleeper.
- You’re looking for strong value with cooling features.
Should You Buy the WinkBed Soft?
- You’re a strict side sleeper needing deep pressure relief.
- You prefer a softer, plush feel (4/10).
- You want a mattress that’s still responsive.
Should You Buy the DreamCloud Premier Rest?
- You want the plushest DreamCloud option (6.5/10).
- You’re a side or back sleeper under 230 lbs.
- You need excellent motion isolation for couples.
Should You Buy the WinkBed Plus?
- You weigh over 250 lbs and need extra support.
- You’re a back or stomach sleeper.
- You want a firm mattress with great edge support.
Final Thoughts
For most sleepers, the WinkBed is the better choice due to its customizable firmness, superior edge support, and premium construction. However, the DreamCloud is a fantastic option for those seeking affordability without sacrificing luxury, especially if you’re a back sleeper or on a budget. Visit Mattressnap for more reviews, and let us know which mattress you choose!
